When you move into a new home, or a set of keys goes missing, the question is always the same: do you rekey the locks you have, or replace them entirely? Plenty of people pay for replacement when rekeying would have done the job perfectly.
Both approaches achieve the same headline outcome — old keys stop working. What differs is what you end up with afterwards, and whether your existing hardware is worth keeping.
What rekeying actually does
Inside a standard pin-tumbler cylinder sits a stack of small brass pins cut to different heights. The correct key lifts each pin to exactly the right position, allowing the cylinder to turn. Rekeying means removing those pins and installing a different combination.
The lock body, the handle, the strike plate and the door itself are untouched. Only the internal combination changes, and a new key is cut to match. Every key made for the old combination becomes useless immediately.
It is quick work — roughly fifteen to twenty minutes per cylinder for an experienced locksmith — and it is done in place on the door with no gaps left in your security while it happens.
When rekeying is the right call
Buying a house is the classic case. You have no idea how many keys exist for your new home: previous owners, their adult children, tenants, a cleaner, a builder, a dog walker and the neighbour who watered the garden. Rekeying ends all of it in one short visit.
Losing a keyring is the second case, assuming your hardware is in good condition. So is a tenant changeover, a relationship ending, or a staff member leaving a business with a key you cannot retrieve.
It is also the easiest route to convenience. If your home currently runs on four different keys — front, back, garage, gate — rekeying them all to one combination is far simpler than buying new key-alike hardware for every door.
- New property settlement or first day in a rental
- Lost or stolen keys with hardware still sound
- Consolidating several doors onto one key
- Tenant or staff changeovers
When replacement is the honest answer
Some locks are not worth rekeying. If a cylinder is worn to the point where the key wobbles, if it is corroded from years of coastal exposure, or if it was a budget unit to begin with, rekeying a worn-out unit only delays the inevitable.
Damage decides it too. A lock that was forced during a break-in, drilled during an emergency entry or bent by a slammed door has compromised internals even if it still turns. Replacement is the safe option.
Then there is the upgrade case. If your home has old knob sets with no deadbolt, or hardware that predates current Australian Standards, you are not just changing keys — you are correcting a security level that was never adequate. Rekeying a weak lock leaves you with a weak lock and a new key.
How the choice usually plays out
For a sound, modern cylinder, rekeying is the sensible default: it is quicker, it is done on the door, and it keeps hardware you already trust.
Replacement earns its place when the hardware is worn, damaged or simply the wrong grade for the door. Many homes end up with a mix — rekeying most doors and upgrading the one weak point at the entry.
An on-site assessment settles it in minutes. Ask the locksmith to walk each door with you and say which category it falls into before any work begins.
Security: is one better than the other?
A common assumption is that new locks are inherently more secure than rekeyed ones. They are not, if the hardware is equivalent. A well-made cylinder rekeyed correctly is exactly as secure as the day it was installed.
Security only improves through replacement when you are actually stepping up a grade — moving from a basic cylinder to a restricted keyway where keys cannot be copied at a hardware store, or from a latch to a proper deadbolt.
Restricted key systems are worth mentioning here. Copies can only be cut on your written authority, which solves the problem of keys quietly multiplying. For shared houses, rental portfolios and businesses, that control is often worth more than the hardware itself.
A simple decision path
Ask three questions. Is the existing hardware good quality and mechanically sound? Is it the right type of lock for that door? Is the reason for the change purely about who holds keys?
Three yes answers means rekey. Any no means it is worth considering replacement for that specific door — not necessarily the whole house. Mixed outcomes across a property are completely normal; rekeying two doors and replacing one is a very common result of an on-site assessment.
Want this handled rather than researched?
Call and describe the situation. We'll tell you what's involved before anyone is dispatched.
Call 03 7057 3054